Albert.................................Sky Flaherty
Bill...................................Jack Sippel
Bunsen...............................Bill Bateman
Citizens of New York...................Josh Assor, Evan Autio, Bill Bateman, John E. Brady, Josh Burrage, Ben Cook, DeMarius Copes, Julian DeGuzman, Nico DeJesus, Sky Flaherty, Jon Hacker,   Cont...................................Jeff Heimbrock, Meredith Inglseby, James Judy, Ginna Claire Mason, Michael Ryan, Jordan Samuels, Jack Sipper, Chaz Wolcott
Crutchie...............................Zachary Sayle
Darcy..................................Joshua Burrage
Davey................................Jacob Kemp
Elmer..................................Jeff Heimbrock
Finch................................Julian DeGuzman
Governor Roosevelt...................Mark Aldrich
Hannah.................................Meredith Inglesby
Henry..................................DeMarius R. Copes
Jack Kelly...........................Dan DeLuca
Joseph Pulitizer.....................Steve Blanchard
Katherine............................Stephanie Styles
Les....................................Vincent Crocilla
Mayor..................................John E. Brady
Medda Larkin...........................Angela Grovey
Morris Delancey........................Michael Ryan
Mr. Jacobi.............................John E. Brady
Mush...................................Jack Sippel
Nuns.................................Ginna Claire Mason, Angela Grovey, Meredith Inglesby
Oscar Delancey.......................Jon Hacker
Race.................................Benjamin Cook
Romeo................................Nico DeJesus
Scab.................................Evan Autio, Sky Flaherty, Chaz Wolcott
Seitz..................................Eric Jon Mahlum
Snyder...............................James Judy
Specs................................Jordan Samuels
Spot Conlon..........................Jeff Heimbrock
Stage Manager........................Bill Bateman
Wiesel.................................John E. Brady